Age Care Manager Dismissed Based On Breach Of Psychological Safety Concerns

Share This Story

The Fair Work Commission recently decided in an aged care organisation case that illustrates how psychosocial safety concerns can underpin disciplinary action.

The case involved a lifestyle and engagement manager at an aged care facility who had been in the role for less than a year when complaints emerged about how she treated staff.

Concerns included her implementation of an unauthorised “points system” that could result in employee suspension, criticism of staff she described as “lazy”, and a management style that caused significant distress among team members. Two employees resigned citing her conduct, while others said they intended to do the same.

The employer ultimately concluded that the manager had created an unsafe psychosocial work environment and terminated her employment.

In upholding the dismissal, the FWC accepted evidence that staff members had been yelled at, spoken to rudely and regularly reduced to tears at work. The evidence also demonstrated tangible impacts on employee wellbeing, including increased medication for anxiety and depression and the need for medical treatment.

Importantly, the FWC viewed the employer’s response through the lens of its WHS obligations. The decision recognised that the organisation was required to take action to protect the health and safety of its workforce.

The FWC also attached weight to the quality of the employer’s process. The investigation took several weeks, evidence was gathered from multiple sources, and the manager was given opportunities to respond before a decision was made.

The decision shows employers cannot ignore behaviour that creates psychosocial risks, even when that behaviour is framed as robust performance management or strong leadership. Where employee wellbeing is being affected, intervention may be necessary to satisfy WHS obligations.

For organisations, the case also reinforces the value of a well-documented and procedurally fair process, which remains one of the strongest protections against subsequent employment claims.

 

UNSURE HOW TO CONDUCT A WORKPLACE INVESTIGATION IN A PROCEDURALLY FAIR WAY?

 

CONTACT JOHN MORRISSEY (0407 069 507) FOR HELP AND ADVICE IN DEVELOPING POLICIES AND CARRYING OUT INVESTIGATIONS.

More Insights